Tag Archives: Ruby Rose

RWBY Volume 5

RWBY Volume 5 is over, which is the que for me to either cry with joy because we have another season to enjoy in its entirety or weep because I have to wait another who-knows-how-many months for RWBY to start up again.

If you’ve read my Volume 4 analysis, you already know how I feel about RWBY. Put briefly, I love it. RWBY and RoosterTeeth (the small entertainment studio who produces it) are awesome. The following post consists of all the pros and cons I felt made an impact on the Volume 5’s overall quality.

OBLIGATORY SPOILER WARNING – Don’t continue reading if you’ve not watched RWBY Volumes 1-5. Unless you’re one of those weirdos who enjoy knowing what’s going to happen. In that case, keep sucking the joy out of good stories, ya freak. It’s a free country.


Plot Pro – Converging Storylines

Boy, am I ever happy to have all the storylines coming back together. One of my biggest complaints with Volume 4 was that RT tried to change RWBY into a show with multiple, world-spanning plotlines. I have no problem with this if ample time is allowed for something of such magnitude. That is not the case for a show like RWBY, where we have roughly three to four hours per volume released in 15-to-30-minute segments. If RT ever decides to expand its volumes to 6 hours with 30-to-60-minute episodes, maybe RWBY could swing such a change. As it is, I’m glad RT has pulled all the disparate storylines back together. It’s going to work much better in the long run.


Character Arc Pro – Yang

I cannot get enough of Yang. Her character arcs each volume have been among the few done consistently well. This volume was no different. Still struggling with PTSD and deep-seated abandonment issues, Yang comes through – again – as both a role-model and a stellar character. While I do have a lot of issues with the ending of the volume, RT managed to bring Yang’s arc to a poignant and powerful conclusion in her verbal standoff with Raven. What symbolism! What revelation! What good storytelling! I think it was overlooked by a large number of RWBY viewers, but the contrast of Raven and Yang in the final scene was fantastic. Yang is told throughout the preceding seasons that she is like her mother. She’s the indomitable firecracker; everyone sees Raven in her that way. But at the conclusion of Volume 5, we see that Raven – who Yang has always longed for and felt a certain connection to because of the aforementioned similarities – is not like Yang at all. Raven is a pale imitation, a broken, hypocritical mockery of Yang. Raven is the false face of courage and strength, a façade of bravery covering a selfish heart. Yang is a counter to that. The genuine symbol of facing your fears, of true courage. What a neat contrast.

Yang 1.gif

Visual Pro/Con – The Fights

Guys – ugh, I don’t know how to say this – the fights are just…kind of…lame now. Action is not why I watch RWBY, which you know from my Volume 4 analysis. Great action is a bonus for me, not an essential part of a solid story, but RWBY has capitalized off of some incredible action in the past. That is not so true anymore. The fights have been lackluster since 1) the death of Monty Oum, 2) the departure of Shane Newville from Rooster Teeth, and 3) the switch from Poser to Maya. Now, I’ve designated this as a con and pro because while the fight scenes are still a far cry from Monty’s Poser masterpieces, they have improved immensely from Volume 4’s nonsensical battles devoid of any kind of established physics. That’s my huge pro for the fights this season. Thank you, thank you RT for introducing physics back into your fight scenes. No more Nora flying in spirally circles for unknown reasons, thank God, and for that I’m grateful. Yang’s fight with the bandits is a nice little action piece and a good example of the return to cause-and-effect, physics-driven combat. Raven vs Cinder had some questionable stuff, but at least there I can chalk up some of the physic-breaking to magical powers. Also, Sun’s gunchucks finally made a reappearance. YEAH! I love those things.

Pyrrha vs CRDL 2.gif

Beacon Trilogy combat…

Now to the con of the issue. Yes, the fights improved from last season by reintroducing physical rules, but they’re still a far cry from most of the Poser combat. Pyrrha vs CRDL, anyone? Holy beatdown that was awesome. Pyrrha vs Penny? Pyrrha vs Cinder? (Guys, I miss Pyrrha. It’s a clinical condition at this point.) How about RWBY & JNPR vs the Nevermore and Death Stalker? Or RWBY vs Torchwick and Co.? There are too many remarkable fights to list them all here! What happened? (Maya happened. It looks great for aesthetic, but it has hampered the combat.) I guess I should just label this #ImissMonty.

Volume 5 combat

Versus Post-Beacon combat

Plot Twist Pro – The Spring Maiden

Here’s the thing: I saw it coming. I totally called that Raven would be the Spring Maiden, but I’m pretty sure I’m one of a very few people who did, because the RWBY fandom’s collective mind exploded onto the comment section when Raven removed her mask to reveal magical-flaring-maiden eyes. This was a well-executed plot twist on Rooster Teeth’s part. Not only did it succeed in taking the vast majority of the audience by surprise, but it did so without coming out of left field. Go back and watch through Volume 5 again; you’ll kick yourself for not seeing the signs. The fact that Raven wore her mask during the confrontation with Cinder and Co. at the bandit camp is what made me suspicious. We never saw Vernal’s eyes light up as both Amber and Cinder’s had when using maiden powers. Raven telling Vernal not to use her powers against Weiss clinched it for me: Vernal could not be the Spring Maiden, and Cinder was about to get a nasty surprise.

RT did an incredible job of pulling off this plot twist with just the right amount of hints and foreshadowing. Very well done.


Plot Con – Pacing Problems

This was a great season in my opinion. Much better in every conceivable way to Volume 4, which suffered from a general aimlessness. That being said, Volume 5 suffered from its own share of pacing problems. Now remember, I’m the guy that won’t ditch RWBY because I’m not getting enough eye-popping action, but the amount of sheer exposition is this season is a bit overwhelming. Then, after extended periods of talking, talking, filling the audience in with monologues, and yet more talking, we get to an action scene.

Things are happening! WHOOHOO! Let’s get this party star–,

Wait. What? The result amounts to a tense verbal exchange and a brief flash of combat to let the audience know that, indeed, things are happening – they’re just happening off camera. Then, we cut to more expository dialogue between other characters. *Sigh.* I do like character and plot development, so… Wait. What? Are you kidding me? We cut away from a scene where stuff is actually happening to get dialogue that doesn’t amount to much more than verbal chest-thumping? *Yanks out fistfuls of hair in frustration.*

I could go on, but I might intrude on the next con’s territory. So let’s go ahead and jump into that, since it’s connected to the pacing problems.


Storytelling Con – Delivering Expectations

RT had a serious problem delivering on anticipation this volume. Plot revelation after plot revelation, potential fight after potential fight – RT continued to set up exciting scenes that they then never delivered. People were getting angry. Very angry. I wasn’t in the camp of those pitching fits and threatening to stop watching RWBY altogether. I thought many such viewers were being far too venomous with their criticism for a show and company that literally stakes its reputation on fan input and interaction. However, I will admit that these rioters had a point. RT failed to deliver on a lot of drama, action, and tension that they themselves hyped. In essence, this season got into a bad habit of making promises that they not only didn’t keep, but kind of yanked away at the last moment. Most of the disappointment viewers felt about the volume’s climax (the last few episodes) had to do with RT not delivering on expectations they’d built up throughout the season.


Visual Pro & Con – Animation

That this is both a pro and con should surprise no one who knows me, because I regularly both rail about and begrudgingly praise RWBY’s animation since Volume 4’s release. Does the Maya animation introduced post-Beacon look fantastic? Absolutely. Would I have RT switch back to Poser animation for the remainder of the series? In a heartbeat.

Geez, guys. Poser is the canon RWBY look, and always will be. That’s why the new stuff will always be at least partially a con for me. It doesn’t feel 100% like RWBY anymore and hasn’t since we left Poser at the end of Volume 3. Some of the characters feel different as well with the Maya visuals, and that disparity in appearance is always going to bug me. The Poser look was unique. It helped RWBY stand apart from other shows. Now it looks much akin to other anime, and I personally feel that to be a loss. RWBY shouldn’t try to be like anything else. It’s RWBY! An anime, video game, westernized storytelling mashup, and that individuality is a huge part of what makes it special. Monty picked Poser for his creation, there was a reason for that, and part of the spirit of the show departed not only with Monty, but with the switch in visual style as well.

*Deep breath.* Rant over.

HOWEVER, the visual quality this season is fantastic. I’ll be the first to admit that RT Animation is getting better and better at putting out a gorgeous show. No one can accuse RWBY of looking cheap anymore. It’s now unquestionably professional-level.

Maya vs Poser.png

Maya animation vs Poser. I prefer the classic Poser style, but this comparison shows the stunning visual detail Maya provides over its predecessor.

Character Development Pro – New Interactions Between Old Favorites

Everybody loves Yang. Everybody loves Weiss. But they are characters we rarely associate with each other, despite being teammates in a tight-knit family. This season we got to see some long-overdue interaction between the two of them, and the manliest of tears were shed as a result. (Not by me, of course. Other people who might have felt emotional at Yang/Weiss’s very touching reunion and bonding scenes.) I just had something in my eye. That’s all.

Yang and Weiss reunite.gif

It was nice to see Weiss and Yang grow as characters together, sharing intimate moments that have so far been kept to more well-established friendships like Ruby/Weiss and Blake/Yang. We know they are teammates and friends, and we know they have a tight bond. We’ve just never gotten personal scenes to witness it in previous seasons. How refreshing to see into Team RWBY through a much implied but largely unexplored relationship. Just thinking about Weiss leaping into Yang’s arms and telling her how she missed her…

I may need to go to the hospital to remove all the debris in my eyes.


Awesomeness Pro – Return of the Gunchucks

Why have we not seen the gunchucks since the BlackSun vs. Torchwick fight in Volume 1? I mean, the gunchucks are freakin glorious. Why wouldn’t Sun break those bad boys out a bit more often? How can swinging a glorified quarterstaff be as effective as shotgun nun chucks? Use the most lethal weapon in the arsenal a bit more often, buddy. Maximum combat effectiveness, maximum badassery, and maximum aesthetic style all in one sweet weapon package. Blake won’t be able to resist Sun’s manly charms for much longer if he keeps whippin’ out the big guns.

Gunchucks Volume 5.gif

Character Pro – Sun

And speaking of the monkey god himself, Sun is just awesome, right? He is steadily growing to be one of the best characters on the show, and there’s no question at this point (in my mind) that he’s one of the best role models RWBY has to offer. What an optimistic, caring, selfless guy. So he’s a bit awkward sometimes and makes cringeworthy jokes. So what? Everybody’s got their faults, and what few Sun has are really less faults and more endearing quirks.

Sun Wukong.gif

I have heard some excellent counterarguments in the past, mainly along the lines that Sun is a flat character, that he has no motives or goals of his own. There could be some truth to that; it’s a good observation. I, personally, feel that Miles and Kerry have made it pretty clear that Sun’s motivation in life is service. He literally just wants to help people (which can be seen in most if not all of his actions), and he especially wants to help those he cares about. That’s a pretty awesome purpose for your life, and it makes me respect and appreciate him much more than when I thought he was going to be that overused devil-may-care love interest. (That was my initial impression when he appeared in Volume 1. I’ve since learned better.) Bottom line: Sun’s a great character and I can’t wait to see more from him in future volumes.


Storytelling Con – Mishandled Emotional Moments

Sorry, guys. It’s time to switch back to some cons after that happy spree of pros, and the first is the flood of emotional flops. The dramatic moments came fast and furious this Volume – how could they not? Team RWBY gets back together! Yang finally finds her mom! Blake’s longtime friend tries to kill her parents! Abandonment issues! Dastardly betrayals! Revenge fantasies! The list goes on and on. This should be a gut-check of a season based off of the content it covers, but most of the scenes that could have elicited powerful responses just fell flat. Don’t get me wrong, there were some beautifully handled moments – Weiss and Yang’s reunion, Ruby and Yang’s reunion, Qrow’s realization that all his Mistral friends are dead – but the majority of the emotional content didn’t provoke a good payoff.

Ilia’s struggle to rediscover a conscience and Blake’s determination not to give up on a friend? That should have evoked redemption feels of the highest caliber. It didn’t. It kinda felt like attempted murder that conveniently halted once it became clear the jig was up.

Raven tries to kill her own brother? Meh.

Yang’s faceoff with Raven at the volume’s conclusion? While I loved the character comparisons, symbolism, and themes, the climactic moment itself was pretty bland considering it was a discovery that Raven is basically a version of Yang who’s been consumed by fear.

These are but a few examples. A lot of emotional moments were completely overlooked or strangely mismanaged, and it’s hard to put a finger on why.

By the way, do you notice anything about the well-handled moments in comparison to the poorly handled ones? They’re short and poignant. They’re moments that seem to speak for themselves. Very little is said, and very little needs to be said. (RT excels at these snapshot moments.) It’s only when the scenes and topics are dragged on and pontificated upon that they tend to lose emotional punch. My advice for Miles and Kerry would be to focus on what they do well, (Brief, poignant moments) and use huge emotional aces only when it is absolutely crucial to RWBY’s overarching series plot. (Ex: Volume 3’s conclusion.) I wish I had more constructive criticism to give here, but I don’t. I can only say that emotion should have been welling out of me at some of the heavy scenes, and it just…didn’t. I can’t even say why. All I know is that those moments didn’t do what they were designed to do: inflict the audience with major feels.


Character-building Con – Weak Backstory for a Strong Character

Hazel’s a cool character. No doubts there. It’s nice to see a gray villain after the string of pure evil villains we’ve had thus far. (I love the villains in RWBY, but Hazel is a refreshing change of pace). Hazel could have been fighting with the good guys in a close alternate reality. So props to RT for his creation. However…

Wow. Epic fail on the backstory for what had previously been a super intriguing character. What could this guy’s motivation be? He’s obviously got a moral code, yet he’s helping Salem and Tyrian and Cinder and all these seriously evil people with seriously disturbing goals. It’s got to be something wild…

Nope. He’s just okay helping burn the entire world so he can get revenge on Ozpin for something that is difficult to pin on the headmaster in any logical way. Great.

Haxel Reinhardt

It seems super lame, that’s all, and a completely illogical motivation for trying to bring about the end of the freakin world for Remnant’s version of Lucifer. Gretchen Reinhardt was a person with a purpose, who made a conscious decision to join a very dangerous profession in order to help people, knowing full well that it might cost her life. And, yes, it did. How does that have anything to do with Ozpin? Yes, he is in charge of training future huntresses. Training to do something extremely dangerous strikes me as something that carries a large degree of risk in and of itself. Could he have been negligent in some way? Possibly. It’s not discussed. Based on what we know at this point, Hazel’s reasoning is weak all around.

A better idea would be to say she died fighting against Salem. After all, it’s already been established that some people think Oz recruits a bit underhandedly for his fight against his nemesis. There are characters (and fans) who are still bitter about how Oz “maneuvered” Pyrrha into what they view as an inescapable decision or even blackmail. If she had died in the fight against Salem, Hazel could have reasonably rationalized blaming an unscrupulous, power-hungry immortal using anything (or anyone) necessary to overcome his rival, including emotional manipulation.


Tone Pro – Music

RWBY’s music has always been fantastic in the past, and that has not changed with Volume 5. In fact, “The Triumph” may be my favorite intro song yet. (This is saying a lot. “This Will Be the Day,” “Time to Say Goodbye,” and “When It Falls,” are all just incredible.) Jeff Williams continues to nail this show’s themes and atmosphere with his music.


Personal Responsibility Con – Does Justice Mean Nothing?

I have a problem with the Ilia storyline this volume, especially with the way it resolves (with Blake forgiving and trusting Ilia completely). Let me be clear, I have no problem with forgiveness. It’s one of the best, most wholesome actions in the world. I’ll go into more detail on the value of forgiveness after I finish with this rant on justice.

Does no one else have a problem with Blake’s blanket forgiveness, acceptance, and trust of Ilia? No? Just me? Like, what the hell? I don’t care if she was a good friend in the past. She tried to MURDER her parents and destroy everything she loved. Then – oh, this is good – when the nefarious plot fails, Ilia switches sides at the last plausible moment. ARE YOU KIDDING ME? She was willing to kill her family not a half-hour before!

I’m not saying Ilia’s conversion is not genuine. (Though I would counsel Blake to be more cautious. Why would she have Ilia of all people disarm the bombs at Haven? If Ilia had been shamming to escape punishment, that would have been the perfect opportunity to just…you know…leave the bombs active and ensure Adam’s success). I think that Ilia has seen the errors of her ways and realized Blake is right. But I also have a strong sense of justice. There are consequences for our actions, and there should be consequences. Do I think Blake should forgive Ilia? Absolutely. That’s a wonderful message and the best thing Blake could do. However, that forgiveness should be on a personal level. Personal. Not in a societal or consequential sense.

Revenge and retribution are detrimental and evil sentiments. I think it’s fantastic that Blake wanted to help Ilia. I think is wonderful that she doesn’t wish to “get back at” Ilia for trying to kill her family. Vengeful glee at Ilia’s downfall or incarceration would not have made me proud of Blake. Her mercy, understanding, and forgiveness did. But that is a personal sentiment, something she should absolutely embrace on a person to person basis.

Ilia’s crimes are bigger than that. They are beyond the personal. She tried to do downright evil things that affect human (or faunus) society as a whole. Attempted murder (not of just any individual, but the leader of Menagerie, which makes it political assassination), blackmail, coercion, treason, and terrorism. Many RWBY fans seem to be skimming over a rather damning list. This is not the petty crime of a misguided teenager; this is serious international terrorism. Such actions should have appropriately serious consequences. Taking Ilia’s unique circumstances into account can certainly have bearing on the result, and that is where mercy, empathy, and compassion can play a role, but for society’s sake and the sake of justice, there need to be consequences for her very real and dangerous crimes. Blake should forgive Ilia and be there for her, yes, but she should also allow her to bear the consequences that her decisions have produced.

Forgiveness is good and essential, but so is justice. I think we often forget that.


Feel Good/Moral Pro – Forgiveness

Now, all that rant being said, I loved the theme of forgiveness in Blake’s storyline this volume. What a beautiful and essential message, especially in today’s vicious social and political climate. It wasn’t preachy. It wasn’t forced down the audience’s throats. It was a subtle, gentle reminder that personal responsibility, forgiveness, understanding, and love are ultimately how people change the world for the better. Blake never gave up on Ilia. What a great story arc with multiple applications for our own world. I cannot stress enough that RT did a fantastic job of presenting this concept for our consideration without pushing an agenda. Blake’s speech has a beautiful simplicity to it that highlights the wisdom at its heart.

If only we were all so wise beyond our years. I certainly wish I was.


Character Growth Pro – Blake/Adam Dynamic

Blake has come a long way since the end of Volume 3. From a scared, angry, and conflicted young woman running from her past, she’s become a wise, confident, and purpose-driven leader who has decided to confront her mistakes and learn from their lessons. Adam had such power over her in Volume 3. Terrible power. Because she had allowed her past mistakes to paralyze her. At the end of Volume 5, we see a very different dynamic between the two. Blake is now the one in control of their relationship because Adam cannot move beyond their history. He is still stuck in the hatred, spite, and hurt of Blake’s leaving him. She, on the other hand, confronted who she’s been, learned from it, and grew as a person. My explanations do not do it justice, but I like the intertwined character arcs and the opposing paths they explore: One of a person who uses the past as a crutch, and the other who uses it as a catapult. Good stuff.



This is neither pro or con, just an observation I want to discuss. Everyone, with the exception of me, seems to think that Cinder is dead. I have a hard time believing that plausible. Yes, I know she got beat up by Raven, encased in ice, then thrown down a massive hole, but hear me out. In the single confirmed instance we’ve seen a Maiden die (Amber), we see that her power transfers immediately upon death. We see the power come out of her body and fly into Cinder onscreen. Now, consider: Cinder would be thinking about one of four people when she died – a) Raven, who just defeated her and threw her from a cliff, b) Ruby, who is her obsession, c) Emerald, her protégé, or d) Salem, her mistress. Any other candidates, known or otherwise, would be improbable based on what we know of Cinder thus far. With the exception of Salem (who I believe to be incapable of directly receiving the Maiden powers because of age or…otherness), we would have seen any of these candidates receive the Fall powers. They were all there where we could see them during Cinder’s fall (heh heh). We do not witness anyone suddenly receiving powers, thus, the logical conclusion is that Cinder is alive. Possibly much more mangled, but alive. With the accumulated damage from Ruby’s silver eyes and that plunge, we might see only a scarred sack of flesh in a dress next volume, but Cinder will be around in the future to further frustrate our heroines and heroes.

RWBY Volume 5 Poster.png

RWBY Volume 5 Conclusion

Despite a lackluster ending, Volume 5 was an entertaining addition to RWBY, and a step up from the dip the series took in Volume 4. Has it yet returned to the quality of The Beacon Trilogy? Not in my opinion, but the transition from essentially a boarding school setting to a world stage is a huge and difficult undertaking. I’m sure it will continue to entertain, excite, and challenge us in the future.

Ultimately, RWBY is about people – people who live in a fantastical world and deal with fantastical problems – but people who struggle just as we do to find our way. It’s specifically about a group of people who care about each other, want to help others, and be the best people they can be. And that’s why I love RWBY. I identify with that, and the most important part of a good story is identification with the characters and themes. Whether its dealing with past mistakes, feelings of impotence, parental expectations, the burdens of leadership, or any number of other things, I think everyone can find part of their personal struggles in the RWBY cast, and that marks RWBY as a stellar tale to experience.


That’s about all I have. I hope you enjoyed my take on RWBY Vol.5!

What are your thoughts? I can talk RWBY all day, so let me know your opinions, dissenting or otherwise!

Also – RWBY fans, I’m sure this applies to you – if you love Science Fiction or Fantasy, be sure to try out my books. Ironheart: The Primal Deception, The Arrival, and Goddess are all available on amazon! Thanks for reading!

RWBY Speculations


Spoilers! Spoilers! Spoilers! Spoilers!

There.  I’ve said it.  A lot.  If you haven’t received the message by now then you’re not going to.  This post contains major spoilers for RoosterTeeth’s animated web series RWBY, which is a fantasy story set in a cyberpunkish world.  If you’ve not watched this remarkable series through the end of Volume 3, then DO NOT READ ON PAST THIS PARAGRAPH.  So many surprises will be ruined for you.  Go watch RWBY Volume 1 – 3 immediately, either on Netflix, here on youtube, or here on the RoosterTeeth site.  In my opinion, it’s the best show around right now, in spite of its anime presentation.  (In general, I don’t really get into anime, but I’m a sucker for a great story, good characters, imaginative setting, etc., no matter the format.  RWBY definitely has all of those things.)  I assure you, it is well worth your time.  And best of all, it’s family friendly, so nearly anyone can watch it.  If you’ve seen any of RoosterTeeth’s other shows, you know how much of a surprise that is.  I’ll be doing a series of posts over RWBY for the next several weeks, partly to keep myself distracted from the fact that Volume 4 won’t begin until sometime in autumn.

This is the point of no return.  Turn back now unless you enjoy ruining good stories for yourself.

So the first thing I’ll mention is this: Yes, these posts on RWBY are super late.  RWBY Volume 3 has been finished for some time now, and other people have likely hashed through all of this stuff.  But I started on the first volume of RWBY about three months ago, so until recently I’ve been way behind the actual airing of the show.  I literally just watched Volume 3 when it was released on Blu-ray/DVD a few weeks ago.  So don’t get your panties in a wad if I repeat things you’ve read many times before.  This is a simple rundown of things that my friends and I have wondered/discussed/argued/violently-shouted-obscenities about over the last couple of weeks.

Why don’t we jump in with the most soul-crushing moment?  I am, of course, talking about the death of Pyrrha Nikos.  I mean, this was the climax of the show to this point, and it’s definitely the scene that everyone is obsessed with, for a multitude of reasons that we’ll delve into later. (Not at all because it left the majority of the audience curled up in the fetal position and blubbering for two hours).  Pyrrha was my favorite character in the show, which is saying something, because RWBY is chockfull of great characters.  Watching her die in what is easily the coldest, most brutal death scene RoosterTeeth has yet presented was gut-wrenching to say the least, and it had me in a nearly comatose state for a good two hours after the credits rolled.

There’s a lot to discuss here, beginning with the question that everyone keeps arguing about.

Is Pyrrha really dead?

My answer?  Yes, she’s really dead.  Hard as that is to hear, it seems pretty clear to me.  For one thing, I kind of want her to be dead.  Let me explain.  So many great shows have slowly lost their ability to generate emotional impact precisely because they create an atmosphere where death scenes are not often final. (Yes, I’m looking at you Buffy.)  Nothing drives the emotional impact of a story quite like a sense of finality, and if the audience responds like this: *Shrugs* “Eh, they’ll be back.”  You’ve got a problem.  To put it bluntly, I love Pyrrha – she’s my favorite.  But if RoosterTeeth brings her back, it will definitely set a precedent for the show that I won’t be entirely happy with.

Now, as to why I think she is dead, I’ll address some of the issues my group of RWBY-watching compatriots have brought up to question whether she’s “really gone.”

Issue #1) That wasn’t Pyrrha fighting Cinder, it was an illusion of Pyrrha conjured by a repentant Emerald.

Nope.  Sorry guys and gals.  This one is not going to fly with me.  This entire theory is based on the single line Emerald utters in Volume 3, Chapter 10 after Cinder revels in the chaos of the grimm attack on Vale.  Emerald, with admittedly sorrowful looking features, states: “It’s almost sad.”


Guys, come on.  So a baddie makes one statement of pseudo regret, and we take that to mean that ten minutes later she betrays her leader’s masterplan?  A masterplan, might I add, that took great lengths of time and astronomical amounts of effort to bring to fruition?  Emerald has never shown any compassion in the past, but the fact that RoosterTeeth gave her such a line does make her seem more realistic as a character.  It does not, however, suggest that suddenly she has repented of all her evil ways.  IF such a theory were to be what Miles Luna and Kerry Shawcross (the writers) intended, they would have built up a bit more of an inner struggle within Emerald’s character arc prior to the Cinder/Pyrrha showdown.  Now, it could be a sign that they are taking Emerald’s character that direction in the future, but the fact that she regrets the deaths of hundreds (maybe thousands) of people as the price of their machinations just makes her seem like, you know, a realistic villain instead of a completely evil villain with relatively little depth.

Conclusion:  Sorry, fellow Pyrrha-lovers.  I feel you, but that was indeed Pyrrha who was fighting Cinder, not an illusion copy made by Emerald.

Issue #2) Pyrrha didn’t “die,” she evaporated into cinders.

This is an argument that I will give some credence. It actually has some decent evidence to back it up, and, in my opinion, it carries the most weight of all the theories in denial over Pyrrha’s death.  Basically, proponents of this theory are saying that Pyrrha has become incorporeal or has been captured – citing that Pyrrha disintegrated into sparkly ash instead of falling dead at Cinder’s feet.  I know that doesn’t make sense, but hear me out.  Now, what’s the evidence? First and foremost, while there hasn’t been a lot of visible “on screen” death in the show so far, the deaths that have been seen look just like you would expect.  No flickering away into little wisps.  No glowing disintegration.  (This is excepting the grimm, of course.  They do disintegrate upon death.  I’m speaking of sentient deaths, specifically humans and faunis.)  Everyone who has died on screen thus far has done exactly what you would expect them to do: crumple to the ground and remain there.  Pyrrha on the other hand, is struck by Cinder’s arrow and literally dissolves from the point of impact.  This is unprecedented in the show so far, so it carries some credibility.  On top of that, consider Cinder’s enigmatic “Add her to the list” quote from Volume 2 (speaking about Pyrrha) and you have an interesting concept.  So far, the writers have yet to reveal what Cinder was talking about.  And finally: Ospin is missing.  Missing.  Not dead.  That is made very clear following his encounter with Cinder.  Even Salem is addressing him at the end of Volume 3, so he’s clearly still around somewhere.  He didn’t defeat Cinder in combat, it’s unlikely he ran away, and even if he did, wouldn’t he get in contact with Qrow or Goodwitch?  It’s possible that he was captured by Cinder, and that is why Salem is addressing him as if he is standing right next to her.  If Oz was captured, then it would follow that Pyrrha could have been captured in a similar manner, and was “transferred” to Salem’s location through an unknown power that Cinder possesses – a power which transfers her in disintegrated form to Salem, where she is reconstituted.  After all, those floating cinders of ash do spring up often when Cinder uses her powers.

Like I said, it’s the most persuasive theory, but I still don’t buy it.  First of all, yes, no one has yet died by disintegration, but Pyrrha is the first to be killed in such a manner.  (I know Amber was killed by one of Cinder’s arrows, but her death does not linger on screen, so we don’t know if she disintegrates or not.)  More importantly, Pyrrha is the first person to be killed by Cinder since she acquired the powers of Fall.  It could be an effect of the Fall Maiden powers mixed with Cinder’s penchant for scorching her opponents.  As for Cinder’s quote from Volume 2, she could have simply been referring to opponents they (Cinder, Mercury, Emerald) would need to keep an eye on or prepare for or possibly just deal with to get them out of the way.  It’s possible she even was referring to the fact that Pyrrha could be used as a means to further agitate the situation they planned to create during the Vytal Festival Tournament.  If so, they undoubtedly succeeded.  The Oz theory is neat, but ultimately unfounded in anything but speculation at this point.  Also, I’ll put up another post later on Ospin and where I believe he is.  Suffice it to say, I don’t believe he was captured by Salem.  As such, Salem was not addressing him as he stood right next to her (in captivity), but she is addressing him from a distance, as she seems to have done at the very beginning of Volume 1.  More on that will also be discussed later in the post on Ospin.  Finally, the ash could simply be a visual effect of Cinder’s powers, much like the rose petals that spawn around Ruby.  Why does Pyrrha actually disintegrate?  Well, Cinder just recently had become incredibly powerful.  It stands to reason that her abilities had been amplified to the point that they had such an effect on her target.

Ultimately, it’s a fairly well-constructed theory.  I would only be slightly surprised to find in Volume 4 that some or all of it is true.  However, I can’t really get behind it at this time – still a bit short on compelling evidence for me.

Issue #3) Jaune’s semblance will be revealed later in the show as a resurrection ability.  Then, he will raise Pyrrha from the dead.

I am still uncertain how anyone thinks this is plausible.  We’ve been given a few hints as to what Jaune’s semblance might be, but there has been literally nothing to suggest that he’ll be able to raise others from the dead. Plus, that would strike me as a bit of a deus ex machina on the part of the writers, which I don’t believe Kerry and Miles will stoop to.  I think there are a couple options as to what his semblance will be, but they will have to wait for a later post.  Suffice it to say, resurrection is not one of them.  Conclusion: This is the wishful thinking of die-hard Pyrrha fans who are desperately trying to convince themselves she’s not gone for good.

Issue #4) Why she died: Pyrrha’s death is a crucial plot point for RWBY character development.

I won’t go into much detail here since I plan on making this the topic of my next post, but this is one of the major reasons why I feel Pyrrha’s death was final.  It facilitates crucial change in many character arcs that I believe Monty Oum, Kerry, and Miles had in mind from the beginning of the show’s creation.  Obviously, this was a huge event in many of the character’s lives, and it’s going to lead to some serious change, especially for Jaune and Ruby.

Once again, as sad as I am to say it, I think Pyrrha is dead for good.

Whew, that got to be a rather long post!  Stay tuned, next time I’ll be back with a look at the effect Pyrrha’s death will have on the characters and the show as a whole.

What do you think?  Am I wrong? Or am I right?  Is Pyrrha actually dead?  Join the discussion, and let me know what you think is going on in Remnant as we await Volume 4!